Introduction
While the author obviously did a lot of research, my main problem with this books is the author’s bias. The proponents of Bitcoin are, with a handful of exceptions, presented as anonymous, hysterical and associated with ad-hominems, for example: “pretend-currency” or “the Faithful”. Their arguments are ridiculed and derided, for example “I’d been hearing this made-up baloney for months, over and over again, thrown out like absolute fact with nothing to back it up”. The sources of proponents he uses are mainly comments and forum posts. Personally, what I found most outrageous was that instead of calling Jon Matonis (Executive Director of the Bitcoin Foundation, who has been researching money for 30 years and held senior positions in banks and at Visa) by his name, he refers to him as “the BitcoinThe opponents, on the other hand are presented as rational, calm, they are named including their credentials and positions, for example “Yermack's explanation is a reasoned and rational one”. Their arguments are taken as unquestionable truth. He sources them from, among other things, personal interviews and blog posts.
Bias continues
The bias is all over the place. On one hand, he argues that “... all suspects are innocent until proven guilty …”, yet that does not prevent him from claiming that Ross Ulbricht is, as alleged by the US prosecutors, indeed Dread Pirate Roberts, prior to his sentencing. When addressing Bitcoin from the perspective of Austrian school of economics, he quotes three negative opinions, and ignores many others who are either neutral or positive about it, and instead of referencing research publications, he references blog posts.When describing the position of the Federal Election Commission towards using Bitcoin in political donations, he writes that their decisions “... speak volumes about the confidence the FEC lacks in bitcoin”. I listened to recordings of both of the FEC meetings which resulted in this decision. The debate was mainly regarding applications of internal regulations and how to technically implement them and had nothing to do with confidence.
He says that he is “... skeptical of explanations where money is involved that are too complicated for an 8-year old to understand.”, yet I doubt anyone of that age can understand how the current financial system works. It probably takes at least a 12-year old, like Victoria Grant. Many if not most adults don’t understand it either.
The economic analysis is a mixed bag. On one hand, he describes the omnipresent hype, fraud, bubbles, pump and dump schemes, and so on, and how they are present a problem. I have no issue here and even agree to a large extent, just in one occasion, he describes a pump and dump scheme and incorrectly labels it as a ponzi scheme. Another thing that I agree with him is that Bitcoin is not suitable for money laundering (for similar reasons as he presents).
On the other hand, he lacks understanding of largely uncontroversial concepts like the liquidity premium and transaction costs. Mainly he ignores the hidden costs of a trusted third party and the property rights enforcement of media of exchange. An example would be the costs associated with identity theft, which he does not mention at all. Without these, a lot of economic phenomena cannot be understood, not merely Bitcoin.
He lacks a theory of evolution of media of exchange, and appears to think that one day he wakes up and something that didn’t exist before is now a “currency”. Again, without such a theory, a lot of economic phenomena cannot be understood.
He complains in multiple places that merchants tend to use bitcoin only as a payment mechanism rather than a currency, and does not understand the relevance of this (he writes for buyers, “There is no monetary benefit … [n]or is there any benefit of convenience”). He misses that, among other things, merchant acceptance increases liquidity. When in Can Bitcoin Become a Major Currency? Lawrence White and William Luther explained the economic relevance of the usage as a payment mechanism, I thought they were joking for writing something this obvious, but apparently it’s not as obvious as I thought.
Jeffrey Robinson portrays, M-Pesa or Amazon Payments as potential competitors to Bitcoin, but misses, among other things, that they do not work internationally. Amazon Payments only works in the US, the Kenyan M-Pesa only works in Kenya. International trade is a non-negligible proportion of global trade.
The more controversial economic topics, such as deflation, velocity, intrinsic value are portrayed in a one-sided way and again the statements of the sources are taken as undeniable.
I would also complain about Jeffrey’s statist bias, but I think it probably would be unfair, because this is widely present everywhere and I don’t want to single him out.
Conclusion
In summary, don’t buy this book. There are better explanations of Bitcoin, and better critiques of it as well (indeed, it’s probably better if you read the original critiques he references). If you want to read more about bubbles, I recommend Boombustology, and if you want to read more about taxation and Bitcoin, read Jason Tyra’s blog.If you like this review, send me some Bitcoins: 1MKkciz5zT4Vg8pxkd3VtAwMMcxyWPiQtQ.
You are right in your analysis. I might have given his advice more merit had he not come across as confrontational. It was as if someone one was personally attacking him. If that helps him sell his books, more power to him.
ReplyDeleteGreat Article
DeleteFinal Year Projects Blockchain Domain for CSE Projects Centers in Chennai
I can’t believe this happened to me because i just decide to give it try, I was reading about cryptocurrency because i am really interested in investing in cryptocurrency because from the books i’ve read…The digital currency is the future, I saw the bitcoins price and it is way too steep for me financially so i had to read some books about trading because that’s the only way to acquire bitcoins since it’s high. I tried to trade on my own but didn’t go through then i began to look for a trader online. I got to a forum on youtube and i get to see everyone giving testimonies of how the Mr William lee helped them trade bitcoins in less than 3 days. I read some reviews on youtube and i decided to continue doing my research, I got to a forum on disqus and other websites as well and i couldn’t get enough of the Mr William testimonies. I am just seeing his emails everywhere and how he help families and more. I decided to give it a try and had to go for his lowest package at first because i am nervous. Then Mr William lee help me trade 1.3223 btc in less than 4 days and i am ready to invest the whole 1.3223 btc with him again so i can get 6 BTC. I just have to drop this here because i saw his info online and i am on my way to be financially free for the rest of my life. I don’t want to be selfish…. You all should contact Mr William below via email leewilliam664@gmail.com and he will get back to you in no time. You will thank me later for this great info whatsapp +14086012169
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteNice!
ReplyDeleteI went to learn about how bitcon works pls and how to use it?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.classicsalive.org/
ReplyDeletehttp://www.clickbook.net/forum/blog.nsf/dx/10012014011418PMMDEGBS.htm?opendocument&comments
http://www.schemehostport.com/2011/10/x-script-origin-we-hardly-knew-ye.html
http://www.delightdulce.com/2014/05/tart-au-chocolat-with-crunchy-crust.html
http://www.flaquarium.org/Explore-the-Aquarium/Aquarium-Blog/April-2016/Wedding-Tails-Hilary-and-Josh-s-Wedding-at-The-Fl.aspx?saved=1
http://www.copyrighted.com/copyrights/view/iapi-hcbg-7tvr-kg5w
http://www.bridgeywidgey.com/2011/10/oreo-pops.html
http://www.economicsofbitcoin.com/2014/10/review-bitcon-naked-truth-about-bitcoin.html
http://www.roadsafetyfoundation.org/news/2014/10/20/telematics-motor-insurance-for-young-drivers.aspx
http://www.bic.org.uk/blog/view/38
http://www.blogcentral.rmit.edu.au/2014/09/family-and-sexual-violence-is-biggest.html
http://www.trashisfortossers.com/2013/06/live-laugh-loaf.html
https://es.steinberg.net/forums/memberlist.php?first_char=n&start=2000
http://www.bizcommunity.com/Profile/AlexAiono/c-670
http://footballrefereeing.blogspot.com/2016/07/euro-2016-refereeing-review-team-no-25.html
http://sofie.org/portal/project-harvest-i-and-ii/more-candids-project-harvest-ii
http://www.classicsalive.org/
http://www.clickbook.net/forum/blog.nsf/dx/10012014011418PMMDEGBS.htm?opendocument&comments
http://www.schemehostport.com/2011/10/x-script-origin-we-hardly-knew-ye.html
http://www.delightdulce.com/2014/05/tart-au-chocolat-with-crunchy-crust.html
http://www.flaquarium.org/Explore-the-Aquarium/Aquarium-Blog/April-2016/Wedding-Tails-Hilary-and-Josh-s-Wedding-at-The-Fl.aspx?saved=2
http://www.copyrighted.com/copyrights/view/iapi-hcbg-7tvr-kg5w
http://www.bridgeywidgey.com/2011/10/oreo-pops.html
http://www.economicsofbitcoin.com/2014/10/review-bitcon-naked-truth-about-bitcoin.html
http://www.roadsafetyfoundation.org/news/2014/10/20/telematics-motor-insurance-for-young-drivers.aspx
http://www.bic.org.uk/blog/view/39
http://www.blogcentral.rmit.edu.au/2014/09/family-and-sexual-violence-is-biggest.html
http://www.trashisfortossers.com/2013/06/live-laugh-loaf.html
https://es.steinberg.net/forums/memberlist.php?first_char=n&start=2001
http://www.bizcommunity.com/Profile/AlexAiono/c-671
http://footballrefereeing.blogspot.com/2016/07/euro-2016-refereeing-review-team-no-25.html
http://sofie.org/portal/project-harvest-i-and-ii/more-candids-project-harvest-ii
http://www.classicsalive.org/
http://www.clickbook.net/forum/blog.nsf/dx/10012014011418PMMDEGBS.htm?opendocument&comments
Game Of Thrones Season 7 Online
ReplyDeleteGame Of Thrones Season 7 Episode 1 Online
Watch Game Of Thrones Full Episode
12th cbse result 2017
Did you consider choosing the best Bitcoin exchange service - YoBit.
ReplyDeleteBitcoin America One of the best and safe way to convert bitcoin to instant cash is exkash.com, Here you can withdraw your large amount of bitcoin directly into your bank account within no time. Do it now Bitcoin to instant Cash
ReplyDeleteReasons Ecoin is the money of the future
ReplyDeletebitcoin price ecn
Crypto currencies were something entirely new not that long ago, though today a lot of individuals use them while buying or selling things
Exkash.org offers automatic and honest Bitcoin Exchange services worldwide. Exkash.org is one of the best bitcoin exchanges in USA that is mostly suggested and recommended by all bitcoin users. Sell more detail Bitcoin America
ReplyDeleteEach word composed has charmed its group of onlookers in the most one of a kind way.
ReplyDeleteChangelly reviews
The blog is composed in basic English with no yearning towards writing.
ReplyDeleteRicona ICO
The Drug Enforcement Agency as of late directed its first-since forever Bitcoin seizure, after allegedly tying an exchange on the unknown Bitcoin-just commercial center Silk Road to the offer of solution and illicit medications. crypto crowdfunding
ReplyDeleteI think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. Link Building Service
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot mate for sharing the economics about the bitcoins at bestcryptocurrencyexchange.io website as well. Indeed this bias keep continuing and never ends, appreciate this post here keep me posted.
ReplyDeleteIt stores records of all transactions that occur within it and is run by a peer-to-peer network.Btc doubler
ReplyDeleteWipes out misrepresentation hazard - Only the Bitcoin proprietor can send installment to the planned beneficiary, who is the special case who can get it. The system knows the exchange has happened and exchanges are approved; they can't be tested or reclaimed. bitcoin tumbler
ReplyDeleteThank you because you have been willing to share information with us. we will always appreciate all you have done here because I know you are very concerned with our. crypto gaming
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot you have given this stuff to me you can’t even imagine that how important it is for me.
ReplyDeletestart here
I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day! To know more about bitcoin visit discover this info here
ReplyDeleteThe signs ought to likewise be sent in expeditiously so they coordinate with genuine market exercises. binance exchange website
ReplyDeletecash is a steady store of significant worth; the most fundamental trait, as without dependability of significant worth the capacity of numeraire, or unit of measure of significant worth, comes up short. ICO Marketing
ReplyDeleteIf you desire to be aware of just how much bitcoin is worth, run a simple net search. If you want to essentially convert bitcoin to dollars, transfer them in an internet market and sell them to an interested consumer. crypto press release
ReplyDeleteCool you write, the information is very good and interesting, I'll give you a link to my site.
ReplyDeleteビットコインニュース
Bitcoins are exchanged anonymously https://www.jetwin.com/en-us/bitcoin-casino on the Internet without the participation of established financial institutions.
ReplyDeleteJust like many other things, the value of 'Bitcoin' also depends upon the rules of demand and supply. If the demand for 'Bitcoin' increases, then the price will also increase. bitcoinvest.cc
ReplyDeleteThough there are dozens of Bitcoin news portals around there, all claiming they are providing you with the latest Bitcoin news, only NewsBTC can be trusted for its research and record. The portal is as old as is the history of Bitcoin. Cryptocoin
ReplyDelete. This implies a full 'duplicate' of all exchanges are put away locally and used to confirm, between members, new movement, along these lines keeping any one individual from distorting, including or making counterfeit exchanges inside the square chain.https://www.jetwin.com/en-us/bitcoin-casino
ReplyDeleteWe're a cryptocurrency alerting website that offers price alerts, percent price alerts, wallet alerts and other alerts for bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies with many notification options (email, sms, slack, telegram, etc). cryptocurrency
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAt long last, benefit relies upon components that no organization can foresee or control: simply recall the high instability of Bitcoin over the most recent three years. iqmining
ReplyDeleteI am jovial you take pride in what you write. It makes you stand way out from many other writers that can not push high-quality content like you. THS it's the only best and profitable Bitcoin Miner
ReplyDeleteBitcoin is made through a procedure called mining. Much the same as paper cash is made through printing, and gold is mined starting from the earliest stage, is made by 'mining'. https://cryptalker.com/bitcoin-forums/
ReplyDeleteReliable Exchange Bitcoin To Bank Account instantly, Wire transfer bitcoin to checking account US bank of america chase wells fargo, PNC TD HSBC Indian Bank
ReplyDeleteDouble alternatives dealers are getting acquainted with fame of these Bitcoins, and its consistent fluctuating qualities. bitcoin
ReplyDeleteThen again being excessively cautious with your influence can obstruct execution considering premium exchanges may not perform to full abilities true to form.Best Bitcoin Trading online
ReplyDeleteIn the manuals of the political economy we meet with the following definitions of finances: Business loans
ReplyDeleteThese countries have economies that are more beholden to national interests. The most extreme state run economy on this list is Cuba, which has a Communist regime that has made slight concessions to economic liberalization. accept bitcoin
ReplyDeleteOthers would really like to buy Bitcoin with debit card. Coinbase also affords this provider and has clean step by step commands on the way to continue with either your debit or credit card.How to recover your stolen bitcoin
ReplyDeleteSuperb way of explaining, and great blog to get wonderful information.
ReplyDeletebitcoin trader
I think this is an informative post and it is very beneficial and knowledgeable. Therefore, I would like to thank you for the endeavors that you have made in writing this article. All the content is absolutely well-researched. Thanks... Best bitcoin 401k investment plan
ReplyDeleteThe blog is unique that’s providing the nice material. Please post more interesting articles here.
ReplyDeletebitcoin trading app
These support transactions help in giving enhanced security to network clients, and guarantees honesty, which is relied upon to be the noticeable factor affecting development of the global cryptocurrency mining market. crypto bulletin
ReplyDeleteAivivu - chuyên vé máy bay, tham khảo
ReplyDeleteVe may bay di My
vé máy bay quốc tế từ mỹ về việt nam
ve may bay tu canada ve viet nam
Lịch bay từ Hàn Quốc về Việt Nam tháng 7