Monday, 17 December 2012

the economics of avoiding real resource consumption in cryptocurrency mining

Readers of this blog might be interested in my proposed alternative to the "proof of work" mining system that currently underpins Bitcoin. I call it "proof of burn". Its motive is to avoid the consumption of real resources (hardware, electricity,...) which proof of work entails. It nevertheless feels, to an individual miner, just as "expensive" as real resource consumption would be.

        Bitcoin Wiki article: "Proof of burn"

The question an economist should immediately feel like asking, on hearing this, is: OK, if those real resources have not been consumed (destroyed); and yet they've disappeared from the portfolios of miners just as if they had been consumed; then... who's receiving them?! And the fascinating answer (discussed in the "Economic implications" section of the Wiki article) is: they go to all coin-holders, in proportion to holding. In other words, a proof-of-burn cryptocurrency is something like a decentralised joint-stock company! (The coins are like "shares", yielding a stream of "dividends"!)

I believe this curious fact has the potential to strengthen cryptocurrency by increasing its value to holders. They not only get the benefits of a teleportable, unseizable, undilutable asset - benefits already widely known about and discussed - but the additional, more "traditional" benefit of whatever they estimate the discounted future value to be, of [their appropriate fractional share of...] all the future fees arriving into the hands of miners! (Minus, of course, the true competitive-equilibrium costs to miners [including profit as risk-aversion "cost"] of mining's various supporting activities. Maintaining a net connection, checking blocks and transactions are valid... that sort of thing.) I call this a "traditional" sort of benefit because it's just like putting a value on a company's shares by estimating its flow of future profits. It can be enjoyed even by coin-holders who aren't particularly interested in holding cryptocurrency qua cryptocurrency. (They just follow the "spend your dividend on a treat" strategy I discuss in the article.)

This strengthening of value is not "magic" - it's not "coming from nowhere" - it's coming from precisely the fact that real resource consumption/destruction (as would have happened under proof of work) is being avoided. And the coin-holding community reaps the benefits!

A final note: the same sort of thing happens under at least the leading versions of proof of stake too. But there, coin holders have to become miners themselves to get their flow of "dividends". Now, maybe that's a good thing in some ways: many people worry that in the future, there might be too few miners. It does mean, though, that non-expert coin-holders (i.e. non-miners) can't enjoy the benefit; and in my opinion, that probably means the strengthening of value will be less. At any rate, there's lots here for economists to think about!


  1. Easy multicurrency mining application & 1-click GUI miner.

    Start mining effectively with your computer or smartphone.

    Squeeze the most profit automining coins with the highest returns.

    Download MINERGATE.

  2. Nice post.Thank you for giving this informative blog,it is useful for all readers.Every one will get some useful information from reading this blog.i get some interesting ideas on reading this.Visit Custom Dissertation Writing Service to get more articles like this.

  3. If you know that you may have difficulties with the payday advance repayment, the first thing you are recommended to do is to contact your payday loan lender in order to ask for the new Same Day Payday Loans No Credit Check repayment term. Depending on the state, there are such options available as rollover and loan extension, which allow prolong the period of repayment paying an additional fee

  4. This post is so useful and valuable to increase our knowledge. I am happy that you have shared great info with us. Grateful to you for sharing an article like this. Cryptocurrency Exchanges For Trading Bitcoin

  5. You have a genuine capacity to compose a substance that is useful for us. You have shared an amazing post about buying bitcoin in canada.Much obliged to you for your endeavors in sharing such information with us.

  6. This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have an excellent knowledge about this topic. Thanks for sharing such a great blogs to us. How To Make Fast Money Online

  7. You have done good work by publishing this article here. I found this article too much informative, and also it is beneficial to enhance our knowledge. Grateful to you for sharing an article like this. Best Cryptocurrency trading USA

  8. The information in the post you posted here is useful because it contains some of the best information available. Thanks for sharing it. Keep up the good work linzhi phoenix.

  9. During this post, you have shared fantastic content about avatrade copy trading. This article provided me with some useful knowledge. Thank you for sharing that. Keep up the good work.